Quick answer
Homeowners insurance pays when a covered event, such as a fire, damages your appliances; it does not pay for parts that simply wear out. A home warranty is a service contract for breakdowns from normal use, with an annual price plus a service fee per visit. Neither replaces the manufacturer’s warranty.
Your refrigerator stops cooling: who pays, your insurer, the home warranty company or the brand? It depends on why it broke. This guide on home warranty vs appliance insurance explains what each covers and how to decide, using guidance from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), the group of state insurance regulators.
Home warranty vs appliance insurance: the short comparison
“Appliance insurance” can mean the regular homeowners policy or an optional breakdown add-on. A home warranty is a third product.
| Home warranty | Homeowners insurance | Equipment breakdown endorsement | Manufacturer’s warranty | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A service contract, per the FTC | An insurance policy | An optional add-on to some homeowners policies | Comes with the appliance |
| Pays for | Mechanical breakdown of covered parts and systems | Damage from covered perils such as fire, wind or theft | Breakdowns from certain sudden causes, such as a power surge | Defects in parts and labor for a set period |
| Wear and tear | The main purpose, within the contract’s limits | Not covered | Not covered | Not covered, unless it is a defect |
| What you pay | A yearly price plus a fee each time it is serviced | A premium plus a deductible on each claim | An extra premium; terms vary by insurer | Nothing extra |
| Regulated as insurance? | Might not be, says the NAIC | Yes | Yes | No |
What does homeowners insurance cover for appliances?
Homeowners insurance protects your possessions, appliances included, against perils. The NAIC consumer guide to home insurance defines a peril as a specific risk or reason for a loss, such as fire, theft or windstorm, and says a covered peril must have caused the loss for you to be paid.
The same guide says a homeowners policy is not a maintenance contract and does not pay to repair items that simply wear out. A washer whose motor dies after years of use is your expense; one ruined in a kitchen fire is a possible claim.
Per the NAIC, three details change what you receive:
- Deductible. You pay it on each claim before the policy pays. On one appliance, it can be close to the appliance’s value (our observation).
- Actual cash value or replacement cost. Actual cash value accounts for age and wear and tear; replacement cost pays for something of similar kind and quality.
- Excluded perils. Homeowners policies do not cover flood damage.
Is there real “appliance insurance” for breakdowns?
Some insurers sell an add-on called equipment breakdown coverage. Progressive’s explanation describes it as an optional endorsement that may be added to certain homeowners policies. It can pay for appliances that break down from certain uncontrollable causes, such as an electrical surge; covered items vary by insurer and may include kitchen appliances, washers and dryers. Progressive says normal wear and tear, neglect and poor maintenance are not covered.
How does a home warranty work?
The FTC’s alert on home warranties says these contracts are really service contracts that help cover repairs and replacements of items like appliances or air conditioning. Unlike a product warranty, they cost extra.
The NAIC adds that a home warranty covers the mechanical breakdown of individual parts of a home, such as the electrical and plumbing systems. It does not cover the structure, may or may not cover appliances, ends at a set point (for example, one year) and has exclusions and limitations. It might not be regulated as insurance in your state.
The FTC lists what to weigh: a fee for each service visit, reimbursement caps, excluded appliances or systems, cancellation terms and a slow claims process. As the FTC puts it, a home warranty “is only as good as the company responsible for coverage.”
Safety first
Be wary of mail or calls pushing a warranty for your home or appliances. The FTC describes mailers marked “FINAL NOTICE” that seem to come from a bank, include a fake-looking refund check and lead to a service contract pitch. Verify with the bank using contact details you know are real.
Where the manufacturer’s warranty fits
Check what you already have. Samsung’s refrigerator warranty page lists 1 year of parts and labor, 5 years on the sealed system and 10 years of parts on the digital inverter compressor. The FTC warns a plan may duplicate coverage you already have.
How to decide in five steps
- List your appliances by age. Note which are still under the manufacturer’s warranty.
- Read your homeowners policy. Find your deductible, how contents are valued and whether a breakdown add-on is offered.
- Get the home warranty contract in writing. The FTC suggests reviewing the offer in writing before you agree. Mark the service fee, caps and exclusions. The FTC’s service contract guide puts it plainly: if a part is not listed, assume it is not covered.
- Price a likely repair. Many failures are cheap or free fixes. Our guides to a washer that will not drain, a dishwasher with standing water and a fridge that is warm while the freezer works show how often the cause is a clog or a dirty coil.
- Compare with saving. The FTC notes that putting the money in a savings account for repairs may be a better option than a service contract.
Which one pays off?
This is our own reading of the sources above, not FTC or NAIC advice:
- Keep homeowners insurance either way. It covers sudden losses no warranty touches.
- A home warranty can make sense when several appliances are out of factory warranty, the per-visit fee is low and a large bill would hurt.
- Equipment breakdown coverage can make sense if your insurer offers it and you mainly fear power surges.
- A repair fund wins when most appliances are new or you handle simple fixes yourself.
Got a repair quote? Our guide to deciding between repair and replacement helps you judge if it is worth fixing.
Keep your policy declarations page, each warranty card with its receipt and any service contract in one folder. When something breaks, start with the cause: sudden event, call the insurer; worn-out part, check the warranty or contract. This is our own habit.
Warranty or Insurance? FAQ
Does homeowners insurance cover appliances that stop working?
Usually not. The NAIC says a homeowners policy is not a maintenance contract and does not pay for items that simply wear out. It can pay when a covered peril, such as a fire, damages the appliance.
Is a home warranty the same as insurance?
No. The FTC calls home warranties service contracts, and the NAIC notes they might not be regulated as insurance in your state.
What is equipment breakdown coverage?
It is an optional endorsement some insurers add to homeowners policies. Progressive says it can pay for appliances that fail from certain sudden causes, such as an electrical surge, but not for wear and tear or neglect.
Does a home warranty cover appliances?
It may or may not. The NAIC says a home warranty covers mechanical breakdown of parts of a home and may or may not include appliances. The FTC suggests checking which appliances or systems are excluded.
What fees come with a home warranty?
Besides the contract price, the FTC says to look for deductibles or fees each time a product is serviced, reimbursement caps and cancellation fees.
