Quick answer
Repair the appliance if the quote is under half the price of a comparable new one and the appliance is still well inside its normal lifespan. Replace it if the repair costs half or more, it is at or past its typical age, or it keeps breaking. Get a written quote first, then run it through the five steps below.
A broken washer, dryer, dishwasher or refrigerator forces a decision under pressure. A technician quotes a number, the machine is eight or ten years old, and you have no idea whether paying is smart or throwing good money after bad. This guide gives you a simple way to decide, using the same rules of thumb that cost guides and repair pros use.
It relies on repair-cost guides from HomeAdvisor, the home component life-expectancy study from the National Association of Home Builders, and efficiency figures from ENERGY STAR. None of them can tell you what to do about your specific machine, but together they give you a decent answer in about ten minutes.
The decision at a glance
Check the situations in this table in order. The first one that matches usually decides it.
| Check order | Situation | Lean toward | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The appliance is under warranty | Repair | The manufacturer or warranty plan may cover the part or labor |
| 2 | Repair quote is under 50% of a comparable new unit and the age is below its typical lifespan | Repair | The money is well spent and the rest of the machine still has years left |
| 3 | Repair quote is 50% or more of a comparable new unit | Replace | You are paying most of a new machine’s price for an old one |
| 4 | The appliance is at or past its typical lifespan and a major part has failed | Replace | Other parts are likely close behind |
| 5 | The same appliance has broken several times recently | Replace | Each repair costs money and the failures usually continue |
| 6 | Smoke, burning smell, sparks or a gas smell | Stop and call a pro | Safety comes before cost |
The 50% rule is a rule of thumb, not a law. HomeAdvisor applies it in its dryer, washer, oven and dishwasher repair guides, and for refrigerators it says to repair when the quote is 50% or less of a new unit’s price.
5 steps to decide
Safety first
If an appliance smells of burning or gas, makes sparks, smokes, or has water around its electrical parts, unplug it or switch off its breaker and stop using it. For a gas smell, leave the house and call your gas utility. Do not weigh costs until it is safe.
Step 1: Get a written quote (15 minutes)
Do not decide from a guess. A diagnosis and a quote cost far less than a wrong decision.
- Note the model and serial numbers. They are on a label inside the door, on the back or on the side.
- Look up the manufacturer’s warranty and any home warranty plan. If the failed part is covered, the math changes completely.
- Ask a technician for a quote that splits parts and labor, and ask whether the diagnostic fee is credited to the repair if you proceed.
- Write down exactly what the technician says failed. A failed control board or compressor is a different decision from a worn door seal.
Step 2: Compare the quote with the price of a new one (10 minutes)
This is the 50% rule at work. It only works if you compare like with like.
- Find the price of a comparable new model, with similar capacity and features, not the cheapest or the fanciest.
- Add delivery, installation and haul-away. HomeAdvisor lists typical installation labor of $50–$175 for a washer or dryer, $110–$270 for a dishwasher and $130–$250 for a refrigerator.
- Divide the repair quote by that total and multiply by 100.
- Under 50% leans toward repair. Over 50% leans toward replacement.
Example, with made-up numbers for illustration: a technician quotes $220 to fix a dishwasher. A comparable new one costs $700, plus $200 for delivery and installation, so $900 in total. The repair is about 24% of the cost of replacing, so repair wins.
Another example: a refrigerator needs a $650 repair, and a comparable new one costs $1,200 installed. The repair is about 54%, so the rule points to replacing, and the answer is clearer if the fridge is already 12 or 13 years old.
Step 3: Compare the age with the typical lifespan (5 minutes)
A repair on a young appliance is a good bet. The same repair on an old one is not.
- Find the appliance’s age from the serial number or the purchase receipt.
- Check it against the lifespan table below.
- If the appliance is in its last third of life and the failed part is expensive, lean toward replacing. If it is in its first half, lean toward repairing.
Step 4: Count the repairs (5 minutes)
One repair is normal. Three in two years is a pattern.
- List every repair in the past two or three years, including small ones you did yourself.
- If a major part such as a motor, compressor or control board has failed, other parts of the same age are often nearing the end too.
- If the appliance keeps failing in different places, replacing it usually costs less than the total of the repairs to come.
Step 5: Add energy and water costs (10 minutes)
Newer appliances use less energy and water. That does not justify replacing a healthy machine, but it tips a close decision.
- Look up the model on its EnergyGuide label or the manufacturer’s page to see how much energy it uses.
- Compare it with the ENERGY STAR figures in the section below.
- Treat the savings as a bonus, not the main reason. They are modest compared with the price of a new appliance.
How long appliances last
The National Association of Home Builders published a study of the life expectancy of home components in 2007. Its appliance figures are averages, based on first-owner use, and they are a decent reality check, not a guarantee.
| Appliance | Typical life (years) |
|---|---|
| Washer | 10 |
| Dryer (electric or gas) | 13 |
| Dishwasher | 9 |
| Refrigerator (standard size) | 13 |
| Refrigerator (compact) | 9 |
| Freezer | 11 |
| Range (electric) | 13 |
| Range (gas) | 15 |
| Microwave oven | 9 |
The NAHB study is from 2007, so newer appliances may behave differently, and heavy use, hard water or a poor installation can shorten these numbers. Still, they are useful as a starting point. A nine-year-old dishwasher is already at its typical age, while a nine-year-old dryer still has years left.
What repairs typically cost
Repair prices vary by region, brand and the part that failed. HomeAdvisor’s guides give a good sense of the range.
| Appliance | Typical repair cost |
|---|---|
| Washing machine | $125–$450 average |
| Dryer | $100–$430 |
| Dishwasher | About $200 typical |
| Refrigerator | $300–$1,000 |
These are national averages that mix cheap fixes, like a hose or a door seal, with expensive ones, like a motor or a compressor. Your quote can fall outside them. If the quote is far above the average for your appliance, that is a reason to get a second opinion.
Our own troubleshooting guides can help you avoid the cheapest of these costs altogether. For example, many leaks, drain problems and vibration problems come down to a filter, a hose or a level, which cost nothing to check. Start with our guides to a washer not draining, a washer leaking from the bottom and a washing machine shaking violently before you call anyone.
Does a new appliance save energy?
Efficiency is part of the argument for replacing, but it is smaller than many people think. ENERGY STAR gives these figures.
- Washers: ENERGY STAR certified washers use about 20% less energy and about 30% less water than regular washers, and over the product’s lifetime they can save about $530 in energy costs. A full-size certified washer uses 14 gallons of water per load, compared with 20 gallons for a standard machine. ENERGY STAR also says certified front load washers use about 50% less energy and water than a top load agitator washer.
- Refrigerators: on average, an old refrigerator uses about 20% more energy than a model that has earned the ENERGY STAR. ENERGY STAR says that recycling your old one and replacing it can save about $150 over the 12-year life of the new one.
- Very old refrigerators: ENERGY STAR says that refrigerators over 15 years old could be costing you about $95 more per year to run.
Those savings are real, but they add up over many years. If your appliance is sound, they rarely justify spending several hundred dollars. If the appliance is old and a repair is close to half the price of a new one, they can be the tie-breaker.
If you do replace a refrigerator, ENERGY STAR says to recycle the old one, and many appliance retailers will pick it up when they deliver the new one.
Appliance by appliance: what usually decides it
The same rules apply to every appliance, but the deciding factor differs.
- Washers: most washer problems are cheap ones, like a hose, a filter, a door seal or a level. The usual deciding factor is a major mechanical or electronic part on a machine near its typical 10 years. If it is a small fix, repair it. If it is a major part on an old washer, run the 50% test.
- Dryers: many heating problems come down to a breaker, a lint filter or a vent, which cost nothing. If a technician confirms a failed heating part, the repair is often modest compared with the price of a new dryer, and dryers last longer than washers, so repairing is usually reasonable.
- Dishwashers: they have the shortest typical life, about 9 years. A cheap fix on a young dishwasher is easy to justify. A pump or motor repair on an older one often is not.
- Refrigerators: repairs cost the most, and the stakes are higher because food spoils. A standard refrigerator typically lasts about 13 years, and ENERGY STAR notes that a very old one costs more to run. A sealed-system or compressor repair on an old refrigerator is the classic case for replacing.
Costs people forget
The price on the box is not the full price. When you compare a repair with a new appliance, count the delivery, the installation, the haul-away of the old unit and any extra work the new one needs, such as a new outlet, a water line, a vent or a different hose. A new appliance also loses its price advantage if it does not fit the space or the hookups you already have.
On the other side, count the cost of being without the appliance. A broken refrigerator can spoil food within a day or two, and a broken washer can mean repeated laundromat trips. A longer wait for a part can tip a close decision toward replacing.
When to replace even if the repair is cheap
Sometimes a low quote is still the wrong choice.
- Safety: an appliance that has overheated, sparked, leaked near electrical parts or smelled of gas should not be repaired on the cheap. Replace it if the cause is a damaged wiring harness, a damaged control board or repeated overheating.
- Parts are no longer available: an old model can be impossible to repair at any price. Ask the technician whether the part is still made.
- The room or the install is a problem: if a new model would also fix a hookup, a fit or a ventilation problem, replacing may be worth more than the repair.
- Frequent breakdowns: if you have paid for repairs on the same appliance several times in the past few years, the next one will probably not be the last.
When to repair even if it feels old
- The part is simple and cheap, like a hose, a door seal, a filter or a belt, and the rest of the appliance works well.
- The appliance is a good model that you chose for its capacity or features, and a replacement of the same quality costs far more than the repair.
- A warranty covers it. Check this before you pay anything.
- A cleaning or reset fixes it. Many “dead” appliances only need a vent cleaned, a filter cleared or a reset, which is why checking before calling is worth ten minutes.
How to get the most from a repair visit
- Have the model and serial number ready, and write down what the appliance is doing and when it started.
- Tell the technician what you already tried.
- Ask what the repair covers, how long the part and labor are guaranteed, and whether the diagnostic fee is credited if you go ahead.
- Get a second quote if the first is above the averages in the table above.
When to ask a technician for a quote
Ask for a quote whenever the problem is not something a filter, hose, level or setting can fix, and whenever the repair involves electricity, gas or sealed refrigeration parts. Do not guess at a major repair, and do not buy a new appliance before you have a written diagnosis.
A simple repair on a relatively young machine is usually worth paying for. A quote for a major part on an old appliance often points to replacing it. Run the numbers in Step 2 before you accept either.
If the appliance is a washer, dryer, dishwasher or refrigerator, compare your quote with the prices of comparable new models at two or three retailers. Retailer prices change often, and sales can tip a borderline decision. Before you pay for any repair, try the free checks first: our guides to a dryer not heating, a dishwasher not draining and a refrigerator not cooling but freezer works cover the most common causes.
Repair or Replace? FAQ
What is the 50% rule for appliances?
If the repair costs more than half the price of a comparable new appliance, replacing it usually makes more sense. HomeAdvisor applies it in several of its repair guides. It is a rule of thumb, and age and repair history matter too.
How long should a washing machine last?
The NAHB study puts the average at about 10 years. Dryers and standard refrigerators average about 13 years, and dishwashers about 9.
Is it worth fixing a 10-year-old refrigerator?
It depends on the quote and the failed part. A standard refrigerator typically lasts about 13 years, so at 10 it still has some life left. If the repair is under half the cost of a new one and it is not a major part, repairing can make sense. A big repair on a refrigerator that old is usually better spent on a new one.
Should I replace an appliance that keeps breaking?
Usually yes. Several repairs in a few years suggest that more failures are coming. Add up what you have spent and compare it with the cost of a new appliance.
Are new appliances more energy efficient?
Yes. ENERGY STAR certified washers use about 20% less energy and about 30% less water than regular washers, and an old refrigerator uses about 20% more energy than a certified one. The savings add up slowly, so they are best treated as a tie-breaker.
Should I buy an extended warranty?
That is a separate question, and the answer depends on the price of the plan and the appliance. Read what it covers, what it excludes and how it compares with the cost of one typical repair.
Sources
- HomeAdvisor: appliance repair costs
- HomeAdvisor: washing machine repair costs
- HomeAdvisor: dryer repair costs
- HomeAdvisor: dishwasher repair costs
- HomeAdvisor: refrigerator repair costs
- HomeAdvisor: appliance installation costs
- NAHB: study of life expectancy of home components (2007)
- ENERGY STAR: clothes washers
- ENERGY STAR: refrigerators
