Extended Appliance Warranties: Are They Worth It?

Quick answer

Extended appliance warranties are usually worth it only when they add real coverage beyond the factory warranty, cost less than a likely repair, and come from a company you trust. The FTC notes that saving the same money for repairs can be a better option. Check deductibles, exclusions and who backs the contract first.

The offer comes at checkout: two, three or five more years of coverage for a fee. Whether extended appliance warranties are worth it depends on three things you can check in a few minutes: what the factory warranty already covers, what a likely repair would cost, and what the contract actually says. This guide walks through each, using guidance from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the manufacturers’ own warranty terms.

Warranty or service contract: what are you buying?

The “extended warranty” sold at the register is not a warranty in the legal sense. The FTC calls it an extended warranty or service contract: an add-on that costs extra and might cover different issues than the manufacturer’s warranty.

Manufacturer’s warrantyExtended warranty / service contract
CostIncluded in the priceExtra, paid up front or monthly
Who backs itThe manufacturerOften a third party, which the FTC says may be a company you don’t know
When it startsOn the purchase dateOften overlaps the factory warranty in the first year
ExtrasDefined by the warranty cardMay add deductibles, fees, caps and exclusions

On top of both, the FTC explains on its warranties page that state laws create implied warranties that can last as long as four years in some states and may cover problems a written warranty does not.

Safety first

Be careful with calls and mail that offer to “extend” your appliance warranty months or years after you bought it. The FTC warns that such marketers often have no link to the original seller, that these telemarketing calls are probably illegal if you have no connection with the company, and that the company might not be in business when you need it. Never give card details to an unexpected caller.

Step 1: Read what the factory warranty already covers

Many buyers pay for coverage they already have. Look at the warranty card or the brand’s website before you decide.

  1. Basic term. Most major appliances come with one year of parts and labor. Samsung’s refrigerator warranty page states this.
  2. Long-term parts. Some parts are covered much longer. Samsung lists 5 years of parts and labor on the sealed system and 10 years of parts on the digital inverter compressor. An LG spec sheet for the LRDCS2603 lists 5 years parts and labor on the sealed system and 10 years parts only on the linear or inverter compressor.
  3. Registration. The FTC notes that you sometimes have to return a registration card to qualify for warranty service.
  4. Receipts. The FTC says to keep the receipt with the warranty, because it proves the purchase date and that you are the original owner.

A service contract that duplicates the first year, or the compressor coverage, is paying twice for the same thing.

Step 2: Compare the price with a likely repair

The FTC suggests considering whether the product is likely to need repairs and checking reviews for reports of frequent, expensive repairs.

  1. Find the yearly cost. The FTC says to divide the total cost by the length of the contract.
  2. Estimate the repair. HomeAdvisor’s cost guides put a typical refrigerator repair at $300 to $1,000, a washing machine at $125 to $450 and a dryer at $100 to $430, as we list in our repair or replace guide.
  3. Ask how likely it is. Many failures are cheap fixes you can do yourself: a clogged filter, a kinked hose, a door seal. Our guides to a dishwasher not draining and a refrigerator not cooling show how many problems cost nothing.
  4. Do the math. If a three-year contract costs about the same as one typical repair, it pays only if a covered, expensive failure is likely in that window. That is our own reasoning, not FTC guidance.

Step 3: Read the contract before you sign

The FTC’s list of questions is the best checklist we have found. Ask the seller, and look for the answer in writing:

  • Costs: Is there a deductible or a fee each time the appliance is serviced? Is there a transfer fee? Are payouts capped?
  • Coverage: Which parts are covered? Is accidental damage included? Can a claim be denied for missed maintenance? The FTC says that if something is not listed in the contract, assume it is not covered.
  • Who backs it: The FTC suggests checking how long the company has been in business, searching for reviews or complaints and contacting your state consumer protection office.
  • Claims: How do you file one, and who does the repair? The FTC notes that a difficult claims process or a long wait for reimbursement reduces the value of the coverage.
  • Length: When does it start, and does it overlap the factory warranty?

When an extended warranty can make sense

These are our own judgments, based on the FTC’s criteria:

  • Expensive, complex appliances where one repair can cost a large share of the price, such as a refrigerator with an in-door ice and water dispenser.
  • Contracts that cover what the factory warranty does not, such as labor in years two to five, with no deductible.
  • Buyers who could not absorb a large repair bill, and prefer a fixed cost.
  • A seller you trust, with a simple claims process and local service technicians.

When it is usually not worth it

  • The contract mostly overlaps the factory warranty.
  • Deductibles or service fees eat most of the benefit.
  • The appliance is inexpensive, so a repair or even a replacement costs about the same as the contract.

The alternative: a repair fund

The FTC says that putting the money in a savings account for future repairs may be a better option. Our suggestion: put the amount of the contract aside in a separate account. If the appliance never breaks, the money stays yours. If it does, you have a repair budget and can still choose to repair or replace.

Before you buy any appliance, write the model number, the serial number and the purchase date on the back of the warranty card, staple the receipt to it and take a phone photo of both. Every technician and claims line asks for it. This is our own habit.

Extended Warranty? FAQ

Is an extended warranty on a refrigerator worth it?

It can be, if the contract covers labor and sealed-system repairs beyond the factory warranty without a large deductible. Check first: Samsung, for example, covers the sealed system for 5 years and the digital inverter compressor part for 10.

Are extended warranties on washers and dryers worth it?

Often not. HomeAdvisor puts typical washer repairs at $125 to $450 and dryer repairs at $100 to $430, and many failures are simple fixes. Compare the contract price with one likely repair.

Who actually provides an extended warranty?

Often not the manufacturer. The FTC says the company responsible may be one you do not know, so check its history, reviews and complaints before you pay.

Can I buy an extended warranty later?

Many sellers and manufacturers offer coverage after purchase, but be wary of unsolicited calls. The FTC warns that these marketers are often unconnected to the seller and may not be around when you need them.

What is the difference between a warranty and a service contract?

A warranty comes with the product at no extra cost. A service contract costs extra, may be run by a third party and can cover different issues, the FTC explains.

Sources